Motion: Our school should trial a later start time for one month. This is a discussion exercise; no claim about health or attainment is supplied as fact.

Assign proposer, opposer, moderator, evidence checker, and observer roles. Teams may argue a position they do not personally hold. Agree that people may pass on speaking.

📝 Prepare · 10 minutes

Check claims before presenting them as facts. Consider transport, family routines, activities, and how to evaluate the trial.

Round
Time
Task
Opening
2 minutes each
State proposal and reasons
Clarification
4 minutes
Ask questions without speeches
Rebuttal
2 minutes each
Address the strongest opposing reason
Joint design
5 minutes
Agree what a fair trial would measure
Closing
1 minute each
State what evidence would change your view
Two-minute speaking turn
02:00

📝 Observe the reasoning

Claims distinguished from assumptions
Other side summarised fairly
A real objection answered
Uncertainty acknowledged
A measurable trial proposed

Afterward, each learner writes one argument they understand better and one unanswered question. Do not score agreement with the teacher’s view.

✏️ Leave with a testable proposal

Use the joint-design and closing rounds to complete this output. Reserve the remaining six minutes of the 35-minute session for transitions and the final written response.